Class Comes to Cane Bay

Saturday was cruise ship day, and we had an appointment to do a 90 minute couples massage on the beach at Carambola. A  honeymoon couple contacted us months ago and we agreed to meet them out there. We have had a few of these nice little jobs since the cruise ships started coming back. Hope they continue.

They were a nice young couple (everybody’s nice and YOUNG these days – I feel so old sometimes), enjoyed their massage and probably spent the rest of the afternoon lounging out there talking about coming back to visit, or what it would be like to live here. They had been to a few other islands and especially liked St. Lucia. They hiked up a volcano there and are into outdoor pursuits (like us).  But they liked our island, too, so hopefully, they’ll return.

When we were done massaging them, it was time for lunch, so we went to Cane Bay and ate at Eat @ Cane Bay, Frank and Katherine Pugliese’s new place. Aahhh! Beverages served in glasses and food served on real plates with silverware. If you must have a traveler for the beach or the road, they’ll give you a regular plastic cup instead of styrofoam. Add $1 for a take-out  meal since they use eco-friendly containers. Love that!

And, of course, with Frank in the kitchen, the food is superb.

Classy beach bar food. How perfect is that!

Menu items include create your own burgers and salads. Starting price for a burger with lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, and choice of cheese is $8.50. You can add bacon, egg, avocado, mushroom and onion, blue cheese or jalapeno cream cheese for $2.50. Or duck chili, chorizo or pulled pork for $4, truffle aioli for $2 or foie gras for $12.

Your salad is $10 with a butter lettuce and romaine hearts base. You can add any 6 of the following: carrots, cukes, tomato, red onion, mushrooms, kalamata olives, red pepper avocado, croutons, roasted beets, chick peas or edamame; 2 of the following: roasted turkey, hard cooked egg, feta or blue cheese, bacon or strip steak; and dress it with herbed yogurt, passion fruit french, caesar, blue cheese or evoo (?) and balsamic.

When we were there, they had a special of fresh local wahoo sandwich and also a tuna sashimi appetizer on fried wantons. We had both of those. They had also just gotten in a 90 lb tuna. We wanted more, but we saw mussels on the menu and had to try them. We had onion rings (yum) and hand cut fries  (kind of limp and oily), but everything else was great.

The rest of the menu includes an open-faced BBQ brisket sandwich, a pulled pork sand, fried chicken, an oven roasted turkey club, mixed fried seafood. Fun sides include the ones we had along with sweet potato fries, roasted beets, smoked duck chili, peel and eat shrimp, orzo salad w/red pepper and edamame.

They have a kids menu, a couple of desserts,  and  a nice wine selection. Two whites and two reds by the glass, and bottles ranging in price from $18 for the Chilean Montes Cherub Rose, to $40 for the Italian Masua di Jago Ripassa.

We are happy to have the Frank and Katherine team feeding us again! Eat @ Cane Bay! Bon appetit!

11 Responses to “Class Comes to Cane Bay”

  1. Lisa Says:

    This sounds great!

    Thanks for letting us know what’s happening

  2. Wreggie Says:

    I hope they kept the charm but upgraded the bathrooms. Is the same bar in use? I know the food will be wonderful. I’ll check it out in 121 days.

    Sounds like the fries were fresh cut and not properly blanched prior to frying.

  3. Nikki Says:

    EVOO = extra virgin olive oil

    The Man and I enjoyed cocktails there on his birthday and a killer sunset, but definitely need to eat there one day soon! Yum!

  4. Bonnie Says:

    They are unbeatable in knowing how to pull off a professionally run kitchen, happy waitstaff, and huge hospitality.
    I’ve been there 5 times since opening day and have and will continue to bow down deeply in appreciation for the void they’ve filled on the North Shore. With casual class.
    Look-out season- we’ll be waiting days for a table.

    Love the little bar pit seating area.

  5. Trudi Gilliam Says:

    Not that I need another reason to look forward to my visit in January, but we look forward to treating ourselves to a meal there. Thanks!

  6. Joe Says:

    They’ve definitely got the new Best Burger on STX!!!

    I don’t know what the problem was with your fries, but I’ve had them three times and they were great. I ordered a plate of fries once, and they came with a “gourmet tray” of condiments for dipping.

    BTW – be sure and try the Jalapeno Cream Cheese on your burger… MMMMMMMMMM!!!

  7. Sandy Says:

    Went to EAT at Cane Bay last week. It was really good. The open face brisket was superb. Nice wait staff also.

  8. Wreggie Says:

    I may get to visit too before Terry posts again. :-)

  9. Gordon Allen Says:

    Where is this? Is this the old Off the Wall, Full Moon Beach Bar or somewhere else? Thanks!

  10. Terry Says:

    Hi Gordon, it’s where the Full Moon Beach Bar was.

  11. Mim Says:

    We will be returning to STX in early December and are thrilled to hear that a restaurant has been resurrected at the former Cane Bay Beach Bar site. We’ve been visiting STX for the last 13 years and were disappointed on our last trip (june 2009) to discover the place had closed. Does the new establishment serve Sunday Brunch? Spent a number of Easter Sunday’s there enjoying the Lobster Eggs Benedict, is it included on the new menu?

Leave a Reply